Sports blogs the way they were meant to be

Sign In

Travis Ishikawa once had a nice power streak over a couple months in 2009 for the Giants, and I noted back then that his homers came mainly on changeups or mediocre fastballs. Since that year, he has hit eight more major league home runs. If a schmo like me can see the holes in a swing, what do you think the pitching coaches and professional video marmots are looking at? 

Which brings me to this: Remember when the book on Brandon Belt was to bust him inside with hard stuff? Here's a chart of the pitches Belt, major-league home run co-leader, has hit out of the park this year, procured by the Mighty Pavs. I wouldn't normally advise this, but check out the tweet-chatter that follows the chart. The general gist of it goes something like this: 

  1. Wasn't he defenseless on inside pitches last few season? Shows how he is now a big giraffe

That's only half true. Belt historically has had trouble with hard stuff inside. What's not included in the chart Pavlovic posted are the actual pitches that Belt has hit for his five homers. From the MLB Gameday records, here's the list: 

3/31 McCarthy (R) 92-MPH sinker
4/1 Miley (L) 82-MPH slider
4/3 Arroyo (R) 77-MPH slider
4/6 Greinke (R) 84-MPH cutter
4/8 Cahill (R) 89-MPH sinker

In other words, we don't know if Belt has solved the "inside-pitch" problem, because that particular problem had to do with good fastballs. Other than the Opening Day dong against McCarthy, Belt has been feasting on ill-placed soft stuff. The updated book on Belt, if only based on the first week of the season, is this: Don't leave your mediocre junk down around the thigh, middle-in. And that's an admonition that applies to nearly all major league hitters, not just Belt. 

Am I saying Belt is another Ishikawa? Not at all. Belt is obviously talented and keeps improving. Specifically, it's possible the improvement this year isn't just hitting the soft cookies out of the park, but also recognizing earlier the good fastballs just off the plate inside -- and not swinging at them. 

Or not. I think this chart is trying to tell me that Belt in 2014 is still swinging at a lot of hard stuff on the inner third of the plate, and even half the pitches at the mid-thigh/belt level just off the plate inside. 

Has he changed his approach from the previous years? Is he doing something different? He's certainly not striking out less frequently in this early going.

That doesn't include the home opener Tuesday: four PAs without a K. Throw those in, and the K% is still 28.5%. Yeah, and if he keeps hitting five home runs every eight games, we'll give a flying squirrel about the Ks. 

But he's still striking out a ton, and also note that he hasn't walked yet. I'm not predicting a swift fall from opening-week grace. Just pointing out what's different so far, and what isn't, and hopefully lending some nuance to the chatter that Belt has solved the inside-pitch bugaboo. 

I'll let the people with more time and patience wring more insight from all this, but I wouldn't be surprised if we start to see a lot more soft stuff down and away against Belt, and those breaking balls down and in become mainly a product of a pitcher's mistake, not his design.

# continue reading
Like the Giants, I too spent my first week of April in dry hot climates. It was rough, I tell you, and I learned several valuable lessons. 1) Riverside County is really big. Huge! Who knew it stretched all that way?...
# continue reading
Two words, Mel Hall, as ephemeral as a melting hallucination, are all you need to know about the importance of the 25 players a baseball club chooses to start the year with. We get all worked up, because so-and-so deserves...
# continue reading
We're down to the dog days of spring. These are the days of Kruk and Kuip filling broadcasts with innings-long jokes about players with uniform numbers in the 90s. These are the days of bar fights that break out over...
# continue reading
They arrived thirsting for contrition, but all they came away with was "get your front foot down and rotate through the hips"!Other thoughts on Barry's Back Day: - If Bonds had been the "hitting coach" 12 years ago, the Giants...
# continue reading
Brandon Belt is a $3 million man, give or take a hundred thou. No silly arbitration fight this time around. The question now shifts to the long term. Do the parties go year to year through 2017, perhaps with the...
# continue reading
Yes! I mean, no! Well, let's talk about it. First let me climb into this flame-proof suit and seal the door of my underground bunker. Until you put the rocks down, I will only speak to you through the communication...
# continue reading
Catching up over the holidays, I listened to the Baseball America podcast about NL West top prospects, and it made me want to revisit my mid-December "Happy Tanaka" post. I'll explain, but first to refresh your memory, I argued that...
# continue reading
I'm a bit late to the Candlestick nostalgia party, but my in-laws were in town the past week and I came down with a bitchin' cold. I'm a big 49er fan when they prove worthy of my time, but I've...
# continue reading
We should learn any day, any hour now, whether the Tohoku Rakuten Golden Eagles, which play their home games at Kleenex Miyagi Stadium, will post their young ace Masahiro Tanaka and allow him to pursue besu-baru in the major leagues....
# continue reading
Yep. Morse is the left fielder. (Good call, Grant!) After the speculation and pre-emptive trade freakout and late-night rumor chasing, turns out the Giants were telegraphing it all along. By now Mike Morse is less a ballplayer and more a...
# continue reading
I'm not sure how, or who, or when, but the Giants are probably going to make a trade in the next few weeks for an outfielder. Perhaps it will be Brett Gardner. Perhaps not. For some people, the words "trade"...
# continue reading
Burp. Welcome back, you and all your turkey sandwiches. If you didn't eat enough starch this past weekend, I'm sure you can get yam-skin wall weavings at a deep Cyber Monday discount on Etsy. Meanwhile, let's digest some Giants news....
# continue reading



Header photo courtesy of Flickr user eviltomthai under a Creative Commons license.