When the Giants Come to Town, It's Bye-Bye Baby

11.07.2008
Groundwork

The GM meeting is over with no changes to the Giants roster. Earlier this week they signed two journeymen to minor league contracts, the more intriguing being Josh Phelps. (The other guy is Justin Miller.)

Phelps hit quite well his first year or two with Toronto, but his defensive lack and apparent 4–A bat have bounced him around the past few years. If he absolutely rakes in spring training and fields grounders at first base without tripping over his shoelaces, maybe, maybe he’ll win a roster spot as a RH bench guy and occasional 1B platooner. Or maybe at 31 he’ll be the next Carlos Pena.

So much for the Giants, though no doubt Brian Sabean kicked mucho tire this week. Were there other deals or newsbits that could affect the Giants’ postseason?

It became fairly clear that Jake Peavy will not be my Padre, your Padre, or anybody’s Padre next year. Kevin Towers said as much, and although he’ll probably get a sweet package of players for Peavy to help woeful San Diego rebuild that much faster, I can’t help but rejoice if Peavy is traded out of the division.

Rafael Furcal is the latest rumor flavor. Do not want. Too much injury risk, and Manny Burriss is intriguing enough to deserve a full time shot at the job. If it were a matter of a surefire All-Star shortstop not only being up for grabs but the possible difference between a good year and a great year, then I’d say put a dog in that hunt. But Furcal’s fire is far from sure, and he’s going to be expensive. Spend the money elsewhere.

You know who would be an interesting free agent to pursue? Derek Lowe, that’s who, especially if Sabean can subtract more millions from the payroll — Dave Roberts and Aaron Rowand? — than anyone is expecting and he can use a trade, not free agent dollars, as the route to a big bat.



Also on the Network:



5 Comments

| Leave a comment

Dunno why we need more pitching - Lowe will want a three-year deal with at least $10m/y. I'd rather spend on offense. Talk to Cain about how it is to have a sub-4.00 era and less than 10 wins.

If we get Lowe, we better spend a bunch on a bat. I'd rather them spend on the bullpen and 3rd base. Trade Rowand, trade Molina, (hell, trade Winn), get some offense where we have major holes. I mean, our starting pitching was the least of our worries, so why spend cash where we can spend it on needs? Cain and Linc will be even better next year, and hopefully Lowry will bounce back for 10+ wins. Say Zito gets another 10+ wins and another starter gets some, why wouldn't we focus on bullpen and offense first? I guess I'm nuts...

And not to mention Sanchez (unless he is traded).

I agree, ixnay on the Owe-Lay, we should not be worried about winning so much in 2009 as seeing what we got in Lowry, Misch, Pucetas in the 5th spot. In any case, whoever is in the 5th spot (or even the 4th spot) is keeping it warm for Bumgarner or Alderson.

Now if Sanchez is traded to get a big bat, then I guess money on someone like Lowe could be the thing to do. However, again, I say no, we are rebuilding, let's see what we got, fix up the offense a bit so that Lincecum and Cain can win a bunch of games. Again, Bumgarner and Alderson are probably a year or two away, don't make any big commitments.

Particularly if the commit overlaps Cain and/or Lincecum's free agency years, we should be looking to sign both to extensions beyond their Giants control years.

I don't think Phelps the next Pena or Cust. He's on the wrong side of 30, plus defense has always been his problem, it's probably not going to get that much better. Pena was known for his defense and teams were just waiting for him to start hitting the way they thought he could.

His stats were actually pretty decent before the Rays lucked into him, not sure why teams bounced him around.

I like Miller, he could be a good addition, I think.

You can NEVER have enough pitching.

So why no interest in Matt Holliday? Is it because they didn't want to trade a young pitcher to a division rival?

Leave a comment