The fizz of the back-to-back shutout blowouts Friday and Saturday subsided today when Roy Oswalt handcuffed the Giants, dampening talk of how maybe, just maybe the Giants won't need that extra bat. Perhaps you noticed: The two pitchers the Giants battered and bruised were Freddie Paulino and Russ Ortiz. Oswalt -- the type of guy the Giants will see over and over again in the playoffs, if they are to reach that far this year -- was not quite so generous.
Two injuries this weekend also cast shadows over the proceedings. Saturday, Pablo Sandoval slid awkwardly at home and bruised a knee badly enough to keep him down Sunday. No word yet if it's anything to worry about, but any extended downtime for the Panda, and the house of wild card dreams comes crashing down.
Randy Johnson's shoulder strain -- MRI results to come the next day or two, probably -- is a little more ambiguous. He's generally thrown well, but it was hard to imagine the 45-year-old making every single start this year, anyway, so there are a couple silver linings if he goes on the DL for a couple weeks. First, Jonathan Sanchez if restored to the rotation would have the chance to prove he got his head together during his demotion. You can't say you're not curious. Second, if the Unit's injury isn't serious, he should still get an extended rest before the second half begins while only missing one turn, maybe two, in the rotation.
The emergence of Ryan Sadowski -- 13 scoreless innings to start his big-league career -- helps ease the anxiety, though it's foolish to count on Sadowski to replace The Big Unit's production for more than a few weeks. Or is it? Johnson is at best a seven-inning pitcher, and with his reduced velocity and lack of quality third pitch (his "splitter"? Not so much), what we've seen this year seems about right: good days, bad days, a few outings at either extreme. Having seen Sadowski's stuff -- good movement on the fastball, both sink and cut, an ability to add and subtract a few MPH at will, the occasional nasty slider, and usually around the knees -- 6 IP, 3 ER per outing doesn't seem too much to ask. Average it out, and that's about what Johnson has given the Giants this year.
If Johnson's MRI comes back with more serious juju, things get complicated. Sanchez comes off the trade block, unless the Giants feel warm and fuzzy about Kevin Pucetas, who keeps
chugging along in Triple-A. Let's not forget Joe Martinez. He just threw
72 pitches in Fresno tonight. A couple more outings and he might be ready strength-wise for a big-league rotation. Quality-wise? Hard to say.
One sentence on the demotion of Matt Downs to clear room for Rich Aurilia: Any roster that leaves Aurilia as the primary backup at every infield spot better be a temporary one.
Finally, a piece of non-Giant news that must have made the Giants' clubhouse stand up and do a little riverdancing:
Scott Hairston has left the division -- the league, in fact, as he was traded from San Diego to Oakland today. If you haven't watched the Giants play the Padres the past couple years, perhaps you don't know that Hairston isn't just a Giant-killer, he is a drooling, moaning devourer of Giant hearts, a filthy nightmare of a beast whose name was spat like a curse from many a good person's lips.
I am not a man prone to hyperbole. Please
click here. Then
click here. In 2007, Hairston hit
7 home runs in 50 at-bats against S.F. Apparently the Giants wore their
mojo bags the right way in 2008, and he was rendered harmless, but he has continued his pillaging ways this year. And lookee here -- the Pads come to town next weekend, but Hairston will be wearing green and gold. Let's all chip in and buy Billy Beane a bottle of superior vintage, shall we?
Finally, congrats to Tim Lincecum and Matt Cain on their All-Star berths. Now do your part for, uh, democracy and
vote as often as you can for Pablo Sandoval for the final roster spot.
Also, remember they beat up on Chris Carpenter and that Sandoval was not in the lineup on Sunday.
Plus, malign Russ Ortiz if you must, but his ERA was in the low 3's when the Giants faced him.
I have to hope that Johnson will go on the DL, allowing the Giants to bring up Frandsen finally to start. Anything else and I would be disappointed.
I can go either way on Hairston. While he's out of the NL West for the rest of 2009, he's with the A's now for another couple of years and I liked beating up on them this season and hated losing those other years.
The key thing about losing to Oswalt that I would mention is that we have been facing such pitchers during the season too and we still have a winning record, and been winning series left and right.
I'm not sure disabling Johnson means Frandsen returns, much as I'd like to see Kevin back up in the bigs. I'd guess Pucetas would come up to replace RJ, but then again who really knows?
They've been carrying an extra pitcher already, no? I don't think they need to bring up anyone to pitch. Admittedly, I've been wanting to see Frandsen at second since the spring, so I'm biased.
The Giants' relief core has had very little work to do as of late... it just doesn't make sense to carry a 13 man pitching staff leaving only 4 bats in reserve on the bench. If RJ goes on the DL then Sanchez is the obvious choice since it will probably only be one start.
Frandsen should get a call-up even if they decide to go with Uribe as the starting 2B over Frandsen (however, regarding Uribe, do the Giants really need another player who swings at everything in the starting line-up?). Whatever the case, Aurilia simply can NOT be the only reserve infielder. Given the somewhat puzzling reluctance of the management to promote Frandsen, I am beginning to suspect that a trade for a 2B is in the works. Along with many others I would prefer to see Aurilia DFA'd and Frandsen brought up even if a trade for a 2B is made. I would be still be in favor of trading Winn and Molina (mainly because Bochy refuses to move him out of the 4-hole) for whatever value can be obtained, although I don't think there is anyway the Giants are going to do this while they are still in contention.
OGC, Lefty's point about the difference in Houston pitcher quality was an excellent one. The Giants didn't batter Carpenter, they chased him with broken bat bloops and seeing eye grounders.
Sprinkle a couple of Panda hits into yesterday's game and it's still a lopsided loss. I think a better preview of what a Giants playoff game would look like (without another bat) was the 12-inning loss to the Cards/Wainwright.
Not to worry, Sabean is currently working on a blockbuster deal to bring in Freddy Sanchez and Adam Laroche to solidify the offense. I know what you are thinking, how in the world are the Giants going to pry away such offensive talents without giving up top prospects?? Surprising as it may seem, these guys really haven't drawn much attention from other teams and I am sure it will only take Alderson and a few others to get the deal done. Bottom line is when I look to upgrade my struggling offense the list of potentail targets is a short one but at the top of it have always been Sanchez and Laroche... eh I just threw up in my mouth a little bit.
Sanchez yes. LaRoche no.
Sanchez would be a decent pickup if they could get him without giving up much (e.g. Lewis and J Sanchez, or similar). I don't think LaRoche is a huge upgrade over Ishikawa when you factor in D. It's sounding less and less like V. Martinez or some of the better options are going to be available.
I would favor trading Alderson and Villalona for a RH power bat that will be under the Giants control through 2010.
I would trade Alderson and Villalona in a heartbeat for a guy like Victor or Adrian Gonzalez although it would probably take a few more prospects. The problem I have with Sanchez is he seems like every other hitter on the Giants. Winn used to have the same numbers he is putting up but that didn't mean he could bat in the middle of the lineup or lead off which are the only two areas they should be addressing. Sanchez has only 5 SB's and 6 HR's on the year and a stiff back that has kept him out of the lineup over the last few days. Does a player with that kind of potential make any difference in a lineup that is filled with guys that put up similar numbers?
Adam Dunn would be a much better fit offensively but trading for him now would seem kind of stupid seeing as they could have just signed him as a free agent if they really wanted him at the beginning of the year. There are other teams that desperately need pitching like Texas, Baltimore, and even Houston that Sabean should be on the phone with every day but I hear nothing about trades for guys like Markakis, Blalock, Young, Reimold, Scott, Huff, or Berkman. Tejada would be nice but I have zero confidence in Sabean getting a deal done.
We need a right-handed power bat, preferably a corner INF or OF.
An outfielder means Schierholtz sits because it's doubtful Winn gets benched.
An Infielder means Ishikawa gets benched.
Schierholtz has much greater upsided than Ishikawa.
I personally like Cantu (INF) or Dye (OF). Being that Ken Williams is greedy, we won't get Dye.
I just checked the Giants mainpage and it says that RJ has been sent to the DL and Frandsen has been recalled. No statement about who will pick up RJ's start but one might guess Sanchez since they recalled Frandsen rather than a pitcher.