All of a sudden, I'm concerned about the Giants' bullpen. Brian Wilson has done yeoman's work his last two outings, Wednesday in the extra innings vs. L.A. and Saturday with 2 2/3 innings to beat the Mets. (Though that 0-2 slider to Tatis in the 8th was one of the worst pitches I've seen a Giant throw all year.)
Other than Wilson, things are a little shaky. Someone put kryptonite in Jeremy Affeldt's sock drawer, Sergio Romo is adjusting to the adjustments that the league has adjusted to make, Bob Howry is Bob Howry is Bob Howry, and....here's my point: Sign John Smoltz for the bullpen. The Red Sox are
about to cut him loose. He'll be affordable. He might want to come to the West Coast and switch to relief, who knows, maybe not, but heck. Make the guy an offer. If he signs and bombs, no big deal. He might be finally done, which means he has five years to write his Hall of Fame speech. But
this writer seems to think Smoltz isn't toast.
It's obvious the Giants really need another hitter. But ultimately the Giants must find more runs from within, grasshopper. No impact bat will be available and affordable at this point, and another marginal upgrade like F. Sanchez and Garko isn't going to make this offense click. With signs of bullpen problems looming, Smoltz could be the easiest and fastest upgrade this team could make.
It was an eventful weekend in New York. Let's all hope not only that David Wright recovers quickly but also that Matt Cain doesn't get freaked out. Watch closely in his next start if he has problems pitching inside.
Pablo Sandoval's home run off Santana after the obvious brushback (brushforward?) pitch was an instant entry in the Giant storybook, an amazing feat on a big stage in a stadium pulsing with emotion. Kung Fu Panda, meet Will Clark in the 1989 playoffs as he reads Greg Maddux's lips to learn the next pitch coming, which he hits over the Wrigley bleachers; meet Barry Bonds in September 1997, knocking one out against Chan Ho Park and doing a 360-degree spin in the batter's box; meet Rod Beck the very next day, getting out of a bases-loaded, no out jam vs. L.A. in extra innings in the biggest game of the year. Meet Bobby Thomson and Willie Mays.
Players of the week:
Tim Lincecum gets the nod for his heartbreaking work of staggering genius Wednesday vs. L.A., with Brian Wilson the runner-up. Among batsmen, it's a toss-up between
Sandoval (7 for 23, 3 BB, epic home run, double) and
Bengie Molina (5 for 18, 2 BB, game-winning home run, double). Big honorable mention to Juan Uribe for his game-winning ding-dong Wednesday.
Very interesting idea that could also be a low risk, high reward proposition. I like it! And the Giants have took on future HOF on their last gasp in the past, so this would fit in, either way.
Though I would note that Romo is OK now, I think. I think some of it was just small sampling effects for a reliever. But clearly Affeldt lost his mojo of earlier in the season, perhaps due to over use.
Yeah, Pablo's turn at the plate is for the ages, I agree, the type of story that exemplifies this season of fighting to prove themselves.
Can he hit?
You make the call.
He hit .274 in '99. I bet Sabes loves that.
HAH
Seriously, with how hard our offense is to watch 3 out of 4 days (and that is being generous) its hard to get interested in a future-less bullpen arm. There is clearly no reason to bother with Smoltz unless he can help us make the playoffs this year which I'll assert he certainly cannot. I'd rather see someone from within getting experience and a worthwhile evaluation at the MLB level than waste innings on Smoltz's final 8.4 ERA hurrah. By god what we all know we need is a bat with some pop in it, somebody, anybody, ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.
2 Questions re Saturday's game:
1) I thought the "unwritten rule" was that if a pitcher plunks a hitter because the hitter is getting good swings, or the previous batter hit a home run, THEN retaliation is in order. I didn't recall the rule being that even unintentional beanings call for retaliation. Am I wrong? Does every hit batsman require a response?
2) After Santana threw behind "Pedro" Sandoval (as the Mets' announcers called him), the home plate umpire warned both benches. However, when Santana proceeded to plunk Molina after Sandoval's moon shot, the ump simply waved it off. I thought the rule was that after a warning, a hit batter meant that both the pitcher and the manager are automatically ejected. Why weren't Johan and Manuel tossed?
Yesterday was ick, but they are still in it. Sooner or later, Garko's line drives have to start finding holes.
I don't know what the umps were thinking about the warning situation. In my mind, the pitch to Sandoval should have been the end of it. Re. unwritten rules, I think the response has to do with the context. Bochy hinted that obviously unintentional hit batsmen dont' necessarily warrant retaliation. He also said, rightly, that you shouldn't hit a batter intentionally just because he's been swinging the bat well. Move him off the plate, yes, but don't necessarily hit him.
Good point re. Garko: he's been horribly unlucky as a Giant. Then again, when you're not hitting balls over the fence or into the alleys, they're more likely to get caught. He's been kinda slappy since he arrived.
Garko's first week was kind of anxiety ridden, but since then he has hit the ball hard - and been quite unlucky. I just wonder how a team or a scout determines if a change of league will effect a player. It seems reasonable to assume that the player should hit about the same after a trade as before. But Garko has lost approx 80 points off his BA and Hillenburg (or is it Hillenbrand?) lost 70 or 80 points off of his BA. I am not aware of any stats that try to predict how a hitter will fare in his new league. I can see the getting acclimated, finding a new apartment, etc leaving a guy reeeling for a week or two, but after that I would expect he would 'regress to the mean.' But maybe that two week acclimating gets the guy out of his rhythm, he loses his timing, etc.
In short, Sanchez (no league change) is pretty much who he was in Pitt. Garko, (league change) is significantly under his AL performance. Is it likely Garko returns, this season, to his Cleveland production levels?
"Pablo Sandoval's home run off Santana after the obvious brushback (brushforward?) pitch was an instant entry in the Giant storybook, an amazing feat on a big stage in a stadium pulsing with emotion. Kung Fu Panda, meet Will Clark in the 1989 playoffs as he reads Greg Maddux's lips to learn the next pitch coming, which he hits over the Wrigley bleachers; meet Barry Bonds in September 1997, knocking one out against Chan Ho Park and doing a 360-degree spin in the batter's box; meet Rod Beck the very next day, getting out of a bases-loaded, no out jam vs. L.A. in extra innings in the biggest game of the year. Meet Bobby Thomson and Willie Mays."
So good, it bears repeating.